Article · 4 min read

Email list health: the checkup every DTC brand should run

Your email list is an asset, but only if the people on it want to hear from you. A healthy list grows steadily, stays engaged and keeps your emails out of spam. Here is the checkup I run first in every retention audit.

1. Is the list growing?

  • Track new subscribers each month and where they came from
  • Check your pop-up signup rate on desktop and mobile separately
  • Make sure checkout and account creation also collect consent

2. Is the list engaged?

  • What share of the list has opened or clicked in the last 90 days?
  • Are you sending campaigns to everyone, or to engaged groups first?
  • Compare open rates by inbox provider. A weak Gmail number is an early warning.

3. Are you cleaning it?

A sunset flow gives inactive people one last chance, then removes them from regular sends. A smaller, engaged list almost always earns more than a big, tired one.

4. Is email pulling its weight?

Look at email's share of total online revenue and revenue per subscriber over time. At Hint, email often drove 25 to 30% of DTC revenue. That only happens when the list stays healthy.

The short version

Grow the list on purpose, send to engaged people first, sunset the rest, and track email's share of revenue every month.

Next step

Find the leak.
Fix the flow.
Keep the customer.

Book a 30-minute call. Bring your questions or your Klaviyo login. You'll leave with at least two things worth fixing, whether we work together or not.

Book a call